От	Mirek Wawrzynski
К	All
Дата	15.01.2007 23:33:03
Рубрики	Великая Отечественная; 1941;

Mieltiuhov, Upuszczonyj szans Stalina, is this "barachlo"?

---

Hi

I would like to ask you about your fair opinion about the book written by Mieltiuhov, Upiszczonyj szans Stalina, Rakurs Moscow 2002.
I put my title so sharp because one of guy from Russia, I suppose - he or she does not want to say his real name and sex (so called Mr Igor) - thoughts that such an author as a Mieltiuho (professional hisotrians) is a "junk" or in free translation - barachlo writter/author in his book.

In my opinion, I do not agree with such Igor, and more think, that Mieltiuhov in his book had made good analyse of Soviet war situation 1939-1941. And more he is much more credible then for example Suvorov in his book.
So, I wonder, what is your fair opinion about Mieltiuhov's book?

Regards,
Mirek Wawrzysnki

---

От	Алексей Елисеенко
К	Mirek Wawrzynski (15.01.2007 23:33:03)
Дата	16.01.2007 03:19:23

Ахтунг! Pozor! Uwaga! Это провакация к флэйму! Нормальным людям не реагировать. (-)

---

---

От	Mirek Wawrzynski
К	Алексей Елисеенко (16.01.2007 03:19:23)
Дата	16.01.2007 17:21:14

Re: More details please

---

Hi
could you be more detail in this question.

It is a serious. One guy called Igor says about Mieltiuhov as a "junk" historian!
For me this is an idiot comments and such a guy or girl does not know what he or she is writing about.

On eto prostyj durak i idiota. This is mine opinion about Igor.

So I would like to know your opionion about Mieltiuhov and his book "Upuszczonyj szans Stalina".

Regards
MirekW

---

От	Администрация (Евгений Дриг)
К	Алексей Елисеенко (16.01.2007 03:19:23)
Дата	16.01.2007 11:21:14

Не занимайся самомодерацией!!! (-)

---

---