Посмотрел. Начиная с фразы The finding of "unreasonable verdict" so as to intervene should be "exceedingly rare" Мда...
1."the evidence as a whole is such that a reasonable jury, properly instructed and acting judicially, could not have reached the verdict"
2."fact findings on material matters of a decisive character are clearly wrong" or
3."whether the reasoning process used by the judge to get from the evidence to the verdict does not make sense in the way described ...in logic"
Вот интересно, по какому пункту новый суд решил, что "вердикт неразумен". Если по пункту 2 - то это просто ооооооооо.
